• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Betting Offers UK

Best Free Bets & Casino Sign Up Offers For 2022

  • Betting Offers
  • Free Bets
  • Casino Bonuses
  • Home
  • New Sites
  • Free Spins
  • Free Bet Clubs
  • Loyalty
  • Football
    • Premier League
  • Horse Racing
    • Cheltenham Festival
      • Disruptions & Cancellations
      • Old Course v New Course
      • Prestbury Cup
      • Top Trainers
      • Top Jockeys
      • Amateur Races
    • Grand National
      • Picking a Winner
      • Grand National Winners
      • Grand National Fences
      • Disruptions & Cancellations
      • Back to Back Winners
      • How Often Does the Favourite Win?
      • Prize Money
      • Virtual Grand National
      • Grand National Sponsors
      • Reserve Horses
      • How Many Finish
      • How Many Run
      • Grey Horses
      • Popularity
      • Amateur Jockeys
  • Irish Lottery
  • Blog

Could the Freddy Tylicki Case Against Graham Gibbons Change the Way that Jockeys Ride?

22 December, 2021

Jockeys Riding to a Race FinishIt was a landmark moment for Freddy Tylicki, and it could well prove to be a historic moment for horse racing too.

A High Court judge has ruled that Graham Gibbons was responsible for the fall that paralysed Tylicki at Kempton back in 2016, accusing the jockey of ‘reckless disregard’ for the safety of his fellow rider.

Gibbons had denied negligence and causing Tylicki’s devastating injuries, which saw him paralysed from the waist down after he fell from his mount Nellie Deen. But judge Karen Walden-Smith upheld Tylick’s complaint, awarding him 6 million in damages.

“In this case, the actions of Mr Gibbons riding Madame Butterfly on 16 October 2016, colliding with Nellie Deen mounted by Mr Tylicki, were not mere lapses of concentration or inattentiveness,” Walden-Smith wrote in a statement.

“The actions of Mr Gibbons were, for the reasons I have found and based on the detailed evidence I have scrutinised, undertaken in reckless disregard for the safety of Mr Tylicki.”

Interestingly, the judge was quick to point out that the ‘finding does not set a precedent either within horse racing or in sport generally’, but you have to wonder how it couldn’t – knowing you could be held liable if taking an aggressive riding style will surely seep into the consciousness of jockeys up and down the land.

Tylicki also queried why BHA officials only find, on average, one case of dangerous riding every ten years, and questioned whether there was any ‘deterrent’ for jockeys not to risk life and limb when there’s so much prize money at stake.

So What Actually Happened?

Field of Racehorses Kicking Up Sand

It was a horse racing meeting like any other at Kempton that fateful day.

Tylicki and Gibbons, aboard the favourite Madame Butterfly, were contesting the business end of a handicap when their horses collided.

Gibbons maintained that he hadn’t seen Tylicki on the inside rail as he shunted his mount to the right, while Tylicki has argued that Gibbons deliberately tried to gain an advantage by cutting him up as the race entered the final straight.

The now 35-year-old claimed he shouted to Gibbons to let him know he was there – a move Tylicki later described as a ‘shout for survival’ after fearing the worst.

But Gibbons claimed he was ‘shocked and surprised’ to see Tylicki on his inside, however it was then too late to change the course of his horse.

After four days of deliberations at the High Court, the judge ruled that Gibbons should have known that Tylicki was on the inside.

“If Mr Gibbons was not aware of Nellie Deen’s presence he clearly should have been.

“He was considered to be a highly skilled and talented jockey, and a jockey, particularly riding at this very high level, both needs to be, and is, able to assess and reassess the constantly changing racing conditions, which includes the positioning of other horses that are nearby, in order to be able to adjust their own riding and tactics.”

She confirmed her belief that Gibbons had ridden with scant regard for the safety of Tylicki – a position perhaps exacerbated by the fact Madame Butterfly was a hot favourite for the race, and was struggling to gain a foothold in the contest.

The judge also claimed that documentary evidence showed that Gibbons ‘exerted real pressure’ on his right hand rein, which was a moved designed to instruct his horse to cut across the path of Tylicki aboard Nellie Deen. Gibbons ‘did not stop’ bringing her closer to the running rail even after colliding with his rival, which caused a pile-up involving four horses.

What Does It Mean for Racing?

Jockey with Blue and Gold SilksLike any results-based business, jockeys are under pressure to deliver wins – especially when they are aboard the favourite or one of the market principles.

With connections and punters desperate for a payday, a jockey shoulders the burden of expectation – it’s not surprising that some will ride in a questionable way in order to gain an edge.

Tylicki’s successful court case is the first time that a jockey has sued another for negligence following a mid-race incident, and while the presiding judge was at pains to conclude that this was an isolated episode and not a legal precedent, how can it be considered anything other?

There are associated implications. Jockeys take out indemnity insurance to protect themselves in such situations, and so Tylicki’s reported £6 million payout in damages will be covered by Gibbons’ insurer. But will insurance companies be so willing to hand out such policies now that the door to civil lawsuits has been opened?

The BHA will also come under scrutiny. Their stewards had waved away the incident at Kempton, claiming the collision was an ‘accidental clipping of heels’, and they adjourned their investigation on the very same day despite only two of the jockeys involved in the race being available to give evidence.

This story has become a major news event around the world, and it’s not the first time that the BHA has felt the spotlight on them.

Previous Post: « How Does the Premier League Decide Which Games to Postpone?
Next Post: How Often Does the Ashes End in a Whitewash Win? »

Primary Sidebar

Blog

Silverstone Straight and Grandstand
Is Silverstone in Danger of Becoming One of the Most Dangerous F1 Tracks?
Golden Dollar Sign on USA Flag
Free Agency: American Sports’ Own Transfer Window That Sees Billions of Dollars Changing Hands
Cheering Fans in 3D Stadium
Which World Cup Has Had the Highest Attendances?
Frankie Dettori and John Gosden
Frankie Dettori and John Gosden: The Best Wins of Their Hugely Successful Partnership
Cricket Umpire Gesturing Out
What are the Strangest Dismissals in Cricket?
More Blog Posts | Full Archives

Archives

Betting Sign Up Offers

  • Free Bets
    • Bet £5 Get £20/£30+
  • Casino Bonuses
  • Free Spins

Loyalty Offers

  • Acca Bonuses
  • Acca Insurance
  • Best Odds Guaranteed
  • Free Bet Clubs
  • Loyalty Points

Major Events

  • Grand National
    • How to Pick the Grand National Winner
    • Grand National Winners
    • Grand National Fences
    • Prize Money
    • Disruptions & Cancellations
    • Back to Back Winners
    • How Often Does the Favourite Win?
    • What is the Virtual Grand National?
    • Grand National Sponsors
    • Reserve Horses
    • How Many Horses Finish?
    • How Many Horses Run?
    • Most Successful Owners
    • Changes Over Time
    • Female Jockeys
    • Grey Horses in the Grand National
    • Amateur Jockeys
    • Popularity
  • Cheltenham Festival
    • Festival Disruptions & Cancellations
    • Old Course v New Course
    • The Prestbury Cup
    • Top Trainers
    • Top Jockeys
    • Amateur Races
  • Premier League
    • Without the Big Six?
  • Irish Lottery

Related Posts

  • Frankie Dettori and John Gosden: The Best Wins of Their Hugely Successful Partnership
  • RIP Lester Piggott: The Life and Times of One of Horse Racing’s Pioneers
  • Going Out on a High: Sam Waley-Cohen Retires After Grand National Glory
  • Can You Clone a Racehorse? And Would Cloned Horses Be Allowed to Race?
  • Are British Trainers and Owners Giving In to Irish Dominance at the Cheltenham Festival?
  • Is JP McManus the Most Successful Racehorse Owner Ever after Recording 4000th Win?
  • BHA Reveals Changes to Minimum Weight Rules for Jockeys
  • Could the Freddy Tylicki Case Against Graham Gibbons Change the Way that Jockeys Ride?
  • The Controversial Use of Drones in Horse Racing Reaches the House of Lords
  • Is Brexit Killing UK Horse Racing?

Betting Blog

  • American Football
  • Athletics
  • Betting Industry
  • Boxing
  • Cricket
  • Darts
  • Football
  • General
  • Golf
  • Horse Racing
  • Motor Racing
  • Politics
  • Rugby
  • Snooker
  • Tennis
betting-sites.co.uk
gambling-sites.co.uk

Copyright © 2022 Betting-Offers.com | BeGambleAware.org 18+