• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Betting Offers UK

Best Free Bets & Casino Sign Up Offers For 2022

  • Betting Offers
  • Free Bets
  • Casino Bonuses
  • Home
  • New Sites
  • Free Spins
  • Free Bet Clubs
  • Bookies
  • Football
    • Premier League
  • Horse Racing
    • Cheltenham Festival
      • Disruptions & Cancellations
      • Old Course v New Course
      • Prestbury Cup
      • Top Trainers
      • Top Jockeys
      • Amateur Races
    • Grand National
      • Picking a Winner
      • Grand National Winners
      • Grand National Fences
      • Disruptions & Cancellations
      • Back to Back Winners
      • How Often Does the Favourite Win?
      • Prize Money
      • Virtual Grand National
      • Grand National Sponsors
      • Reserve Horses
      • How Many Finish
      • How Many Run
      • Grey Horses
      • Popularity
      • Amateur Jockeys
  • Irish Lottery
  • Blog

Could English Football Be First to Get Rid of VAR (Video Assistant Referee)?

5 September, 2022

VAR Clipboard on Empty ChairThe idea behind the use of video technology in football – to make the referee’s decision easier and get more big calls right – is sound enough.

But its application? That remains a moot point amongst many lovers of the beautiful game.

There were two more flashpoints early in September where VAR officials objectively got their decisions wrong, and so bad were these gaffes that the Professional Game Match Officials’ Board (PGMOL) admitted culpability and would answer any review conducted by the Premier League or Football Association.

VAR’s Darkest Hour

Black Football in Shadows

The two incidents happened just minutes apart on Saturday September 3, and this was arguably the bleakest day yet for VAR application in the Premier League.

Chelsea v West Ham United

West Ham were denied a late equaliser against Chelsea when Jarrod Bowen was adjudged to have fouled Edouard Mendy in the build-up to Maxwel Cornet’s goal – a verdict that looked fanciful at best even after witnessing a handful of replays.

The on-field referee, Andy Madley, initially allowed the goal to stand, but after some toing and froing at VAR headquarters the video official, Jarred Gillett, recommended that Madley should take another look at the incident on the screen at pitch side – in the majority of instances, this leads to the ref instantly overturning their own decision.

And that’s what happened here, with Madley disallowing the ‘goal’ and costing the Hammers a share of the points.

West Ham boss David Moyes was understandably incensed, and he confirmed ‘….I’m actually more embarrassed for the guy who did the VAR than I am even for the referee.’

West Ham’s equaliser has been disallowed…

Do you agree with the decision? 🤔#CHEWHU pic.twitter.com/WRmUgBQQ5t

— Match of the Day (@BBCMOTD) September 3, 2022

Newcastle United v Crystal Palace

A few hundred miles away in Newcastle, the Magpies were left incensed when they also had a seemingly fair goal ruled out by the video official.

A skirmish a couple of yards from the Crystal Palace goal saw full back Tyrick Mitchell put the ball in his own net, and on-field referee Michael Salisbury had no hesitation in pointing to the centre circle.

But VAR chief Lee Mason had other ideas, and he was of the opinion that Newcastle attacker Joe Willock had fouled Palace goalkeeper Vincent Guaita in the build-up….although replays suggest that Mitchell himself had pushed Willock into his own shot stopper.

Eddie Howe was dismayed but rather more conservative in his comments than Moyes, although Alan Shearer was spitting feathers on Match of the Day – he described Mason’s call as ‘shocking, abysmal, disgraceful.’

“VAR is not the problem, it is the people who are running it,” claimed the former Newcastle and England frontman.

Does the Referee Have to Change Their Decision Following VAR Review?

U Turn Circular Road SignIn both of those instances, the on-field referee was ‘invited’ to take a second look at the screen by the VAR official. That applies a sort of invisible pressure to the ref, who must feel duty bound to overturn their own verdict.

But not so Michael Oliver, who became one of the first referees to use the pitch side screen following a VAR referral and still stick to his original verdict. He had initially given a handball to Nottingham Forest against Bournemouth, and after consulting the video he decided his call was the correct one and confirmed the penalty for the Tricky Trees.

The former Premier League official Keith Hackett praised Oliver, who will be England’s refereeing representative at the 2022 World Cup, commenting:

“He has got the decision right and great credit to Michael Oliver, to go to the screen and be one of the very few referees to say ‘get lost, I am staying with my decision’, and of course we have the correct outcome.”

The problem, it seems, is not in the use of video technology as a whole but the way it is implemented. More and more VAR officials are breaching the International Football Association Board (IFAB) rules on the use of video replays, which state that intervention should only be forthcoming when the referee:

  • Has made a ‘clear and obvious error’
  • Or to officiate a ‘serious missed incident’

Could the Newcastle or West Ham goals fall under these criteria? At best you could query the on-field referee’s decision, but both were judgement calls as interpreted by the official.

Clear and obvious error? No chance. Serious missed incident? No way.

During the first half of the 2021/22 season, there were 49 incidences where the VAR official recommended the on-field referee took a look at the video replay. What percentage of those were ‘clear and obvious error’ or a ‘serious missed incident’?

The issue with VAR is that it hasn’t made football officiating more transparent, reliable or successful….it has simply muddied the water yet further.

Like the ‘man shouts at cloud’ skit from The Simpsons, irate football fans are taking their anger out on harmless video recorders and TV screens. But the real enemy of VAR is the individuals operating the technology – the human beings who are still making bad decisions despite the fact they have buttons in front of them marked ‘rewind’, ‘slow motion’ and ‘pause’.

And that, ultimately, will remain the concept’s undoing until the end of time….

Is This the End for VAR?

Close Up of TV Camera at Football Stadium

It’s worth remembering that the EFL and lower leagues of English football don’t have VAR in play – that’s largely due to logistical reasons, but it goes to show that video technology doesn’t have to pervade the beautiful game if governing bodies don’t want it to.

The issue is that VAR’s modus operandi – to ensure justice is done on the pitch and results are fair and not skewed by refereeing errors – is not being upheld, and you do wonder how long it will be before a referendum is held as to its continued usage.

Premier League chiefs gave VAR the thumbs up in 2018, and so by 2023 we will have had five years of the tainted tech. Could another vote on its future implementation be held then?

Previous Post: « Crypto.com Loses Champions League Deal Amid Coin Market Plunge
Next Post: The Earliest Premier League Sackings: Which Managers Lasted the Least Time Into the New Season? »

Primary Sidebar

Blog

Number 50 Arrow Target
Do Teams with 50 Points at Halfway Always Go On to Win the Premier League?
Red Card Held Against Blue Stadium Seats
UEFA Change Financial Fair Play Rules to Close ‘Chelsea Loophole’ on Long Player Contracts
Rugby Player Being Tackled
What Is a High Tackle In Rugby and How are the Rules Changing?
Football with Blank White Cards
What Is a White Card In Football?
Football Manager Holding Up Tactics Board
Do Football Clubs Always Improve When Appointing a New Manager?
More Blog Posts | Full Archives

Archives

Betting Sign Up Offers

  • Free Bets
    • Bet £5 Get £20/£30+
    • Bet £10 Get £30/£40+
    • Casino Free Bets
  • Casino Bonuses
  • Free Spins

Loyalty Offers

  • Acca Bonuses
  • Acca Insurance
  • Best Odds Guaranteed
  • Free Bet Clubs
  • Loyalty Points

Major Events

  • Grand National
    • How to Pick the Grand National Winner
    • Grand National Winners
    • Grand National Fences
    • Prize Money
    • Disruptions & Cancellations
    • Back to Back Winners
    • How Often Does the Favourite Win?
    • What Is the Virtual Grand National?
    • Grand National Sponsors
    • Reserve Horses
    • How Many Horses Finish?
    • How Many Horses Run?
    • Most Successful Owners
    • Changes Over Time
    • Female Jockeys
    • Grey Horses in the Grand National
    • Amateur Jockeys
    • Popularity
  • Cheltenham Festival
    • Festival Disruptions & Cancellations
    • Old Course v New Course
    • The Prestbury Cup
    • Top Trainers
    • Top Jockeys
    • Amateur Races
  • Premier League
    • Without the Big Six?
  • Irish Lottery

Related Posts

  • Do Teams with 50 Points at Halfway Always Go On to Win the Premier League?
  • UEFA Change Financial Fair Play Rules to Close ‘Chelsea Loophole’ on Long Player Contracts
  • What Is a White Card In Football?
  • Do Football Clubs Always Improve When Appointing a New Manager?
  • Who Is the Greatest Football Manager of All Time?
  • Is 2022/23 Liverpool's Worst Ever Premier League Season?
  • Which Teams Have Never Been Relegated from the Premier League?
  • Will Qatar Buy a British Football Club and Double-Down on World Cup 2022?
  • Are Juventus In Danger of Going Out of Business?
  • Can a Country Change the Football Governing Body They Play Under?

Betting Blog

  • American Football
  • Athletics
  • Betting Industry
  • Boxing
  • Cricket
  • Darts
  • Football
  • General
  • Golf
  • Horse Racing
  • Motor Racing
  • Politics
  • Rugby
  • Snooker
  • Tennis
betting-sites.co.uk
gambling-sites.co.uk

Copyright © 2023 Betting-Offers.com | BeGambleAware.org 18+